Skip to main content
Report 1 August 2024

Our response to the Scottish Law Commission’s discussion paper on tenement law: compulsory owners’ associations

Location notice

Please note that this page contains information and links most relevant for people living in Scotland.

3. (a) Should the Owners' Association (OA) be subject to the following mandatory duties:

(iii) To hold an annual general meeting of members within 12 months of the creation of the OA, and in every 15 months thereafter?

We think that the OA should be subject to a mandatory duty to hold an annual general meeting of members within 12 months of the creation of the OA, and in every 15 months thereafter.

As the discussion paper notes there’s currently no mechanism within the existing law that either encourages or compels owners to coordinate with each other on the maintenance of the building. And the establishment of a compulsory owners’ association doesn’t in any way guarantee that owners will actually meet or that they’ll make decisions about the upkeep of their building.

We therefore believe that any OA regime must be include a requirement that OAs meet at regular intervals.  

(iv) To approve an annual budget?

Yes, we think that the OA should be subject to a mandatory duty to approve an annual budget.  

13. (a) After a fixed period, should legislation disapply existing title conditions to the extent that they modify the application of the OA scheme?

Yes, after a fixed period, legislation should disapply existing title conditions to the extent that they modify the application of the OA scheme.

We think that this is important because this should make it easier for tenement owners to navigate requirements and for them to get advice on the rules that apply.  

31. In legislation introducing the OA regime:

(a) Should maintenance be defined to include: (i) any work to scheme property required to comply with the duty currently set out in section 8 of the 2004 Act; and (ii) routine maintenance as currently defined by TMS r 1.5?

Yes, maintenance should be defined to include any work required to ensure the compliance of scheme property with the duty currently set out in section 8 of the 2004 Act and should also include other routine works of maintenance as currently defined by TMS r 1.5.  

As the discussion paper notes, this should help to clarify the meaning of maintenance for the purposes of the OAS.  

We also think that greater clarity around the definition of ‘insulation’ for the purposes of TMS r1.5 would be helpful (although we aren’t clear whether it’s within the scope of this work to provide this) and subsequently for the purposes of the OAS.

The cost and level of disruption caused by installing different types of insulation can vary considerably – from installing loft insulation which typically involves little disruption and can be installed for little over £1,000, to installing solid wall insulation which can involve considerable disruption and cost tens of thousands of pounds.

Given the implications for how decisions are made and how the costs should be shared between the individual owners we think the provision of clarity around this issue is important.  

(b) Are any other changes to 'maintenance' as defined in TMS r 1.5 required? If so, what changes are required and why?

We aren’t aware of any changes to ‘maintenance’ as defined in TMS r 1.5 that are required at the time of writing.

However, we note that changes to the definition of ‘maintenance’ in TMS r1.5 will be required in the future to include the measures required under standards introduced by the forthcoming Heat in Buildings Bill.

We note that decisions about what measures will be included under any standard have still to be taken but that the Scottish Government’s current intention is to introduce a Heat in Buildings Bill during this parliamentary session and such the standard is likely to have been agreed (although possibly not have come into force) before legislation introducing the OA regime is introduced.  

39. In the Owners' Association Scheme (OAS):

(a) Should decisions to exercise the powers of the OA generally be taken by a simple majority of votes allocated? If not, what alternative threshold do you suggest?

We agree that decisions to exercise the powers of the OA generally should be taken by a simple majority of votes allocated.  

(b) Where votes are tied, so that 50% of votes are in favour of a decision, should that be sufficient to allow the decision to be made?

We agree with the proposal that where votes are tied so that 50% of votes are in favour of a decision that should be sufficient to allow the decision to be made.  

(c) Should decisions which require a special majority be taken by 75% of votes allocated? If not, what alternative threshold do you suggest?

We agree with the discussion paper’s suggestion that “it is not desirable in policy terms for the law to produce an outcome in which the owner who chooses not to engage is preferred.”

In this context we agree that the introduction of a special majority rule in the OAS for decisions which may require unanimity under the current law would be appropriate. We also agree that a threshold of 75% of votes in favour may be reasonable.  

(d) Which decisions should require a special majority?

We agree that special majority decisions should be required in relation to:

  • The improvement and alterations to, or replacement of scheme property.
  • Making payments from any reserve fund maintained by the tenement.  

Latest news

Go to news

Our response to the October 2024 energy price cap announcement

23 August 2024

Our response to the October 2024 energy price cap announcement, with commentary from Energy Saving Trust chief executive Mike Thornton.

Our response to the watering down of net zero targets

21 September 2023

We were disappointed to hear of the UK government’s decision to delay key green targets. Our head of policy, Stew Horne, reacts…

UK Government must help shield households from impacts of rising energy costs

26 August 2022

Today’s news of a further increase to the price cap on energy bills will be very concerning for people across Great Britain.

Our response to the BEIS Committee’s energy pricing and the future of the energy market report

26 July 2022

The report urges the UK Government to update its support package to help the most vulnerable households with soaring energy bills.

Last updated: 22 October 2024